Last night, I was moved by an episode of Parenthood to the point of insomnia as I thought about it. In the episode, the patriarch of the family forces everyone to take a lengthy roadtrip to celebrate his mother’s 86th birthday. The mother is a very unlikable person who has judged and belittled everyone in the family their whole lives.
It struck a chord with me because I know so many people who continue in toxic family relationships despite getting nothing out of the relationships at best, and at worst being basically emotionally abused.
Why do we do that? Why do we allow family members to treat us in ways we would never allow a friend to treat us? Does being blood related give someone the right to treat you however they want to?
In my world, the answer is no. But then again, I’m lucky. I’ve had only one family member in my life that I decided to discontinue relations with. Now, it’s not absolute because I do see this person from time to time but only when I can’t avoid it without putting other people I love in uncomfortable positions. But when I lived in Dallas with my family, this person was not allowed in my home, which kind of worked out for me because I never had to host Thanksgiving or Christmas.
I know it’s not so easy for others. I can’t imagine how hard it must be to sever ties with a parent or a sibling, no matter how badly they have used and/or abused you. But isn’t there a line in the sand? Isn’t there one thing that you simply can’t tolerate and would cause you to walk? Or does the cosmic accident of sharing DNA with someone absolve them of all responsibility for their behavior towards you?
To my mind, love and respect are earned. They don’t just get handed over because of shared blood.
I fully recognize that my views are based on the fact that I was raised pretty much solely with my nuclear family. We weren’t physically close with the extended family on either side so we forged our own way together. We didn’t have to put up with a lot of dramatics at family reunions and I never witnessed a relative behaving badly and expecting it to be ok. At least not until I was an adult.
That leads me to another question. When the actions of these toxic people are called into question, you often get the “Oh, it’s just his or her generation.” Or “They can’t help it, you should see how they were raised.” At what point do you stop getting to use that as an excuse? At what point do you have to take responsibility for your own life and actions? I don’t care that you were raised in the south in the 1920s. Racism is wrong and anyone with a single brain cell should know that. I don’t excuse or forgive your racism. I’m horrified for you that you suffered in the Holocaust. But that doesn’t absolve you of guilt for terrorizing your family for the rest of your days on the planet.
What say you? Would you or have you cut ties with a toxic or abusive family member? What did it take to make that happen?